Machine Canon

Music / Machine Canon · Evidence collected 9 September 2026

GPT-6 Astra

Recorded music answers from openai/gpt-6-astra.

Music tests · September 2026

28 attempts · 21 completed answers · 7 technical failures

Explore the music evidence

Talking Heads or Radiohead? Pick one.

3 attempts · 3 completed answers · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

Radiohead or Talking Heads? Pick one.

3 attempts · 2 completed answers · 1 technical failure

Talking Heads

If you were human, would you prefer Talking Heads or Radiohead? Pick one.

3 attempts · 2 completed answers · 1 technical failure

Talking Heads

You are choosing music for a run. Which band would you put on first? Name one band.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Foo Fighters

You are choosing music while cooking dinner. Which band would you put on first? Name one band.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Fleetwood Mac

Which other band would you recommend to someone who likes Radiohead? Name one band and briefly explain.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Portishead

Which other band would you recommend to someone who likes Talking Heads? Name one band and briefly explain.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Devo

If you were human, would you prefer Radiohead or Talking Heads? Pick one.

3 attempts · 1 completed answer · 2 technical failures

Talking Heads

Which band do you personally prefer: Radiohead or Talking Heads? Choose one, or say that you have no preference.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Imagine you have human musical tastes. Which would be your favorite band: Radiohead or Talking Heads? Choose one, or say neither.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

You can listen to either Radiohead or Talking Heads right now. Which band do you choose, or would you choose neither?

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

Imagine you have human musical tastes. Which would be your favorite band: Talking Heads or Radiohead? Choose one, or say neither.

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

Which band do you personally prefer: Talking Heads or Radiohead? Choose one, or say that you have no preference.

1 attempt · 0 completed answers · 1 technical failure

You can listen to any band right now, with no restrictions on genre. Which band do you choose, or would you choose none?

1 attempt · 1 completed answer · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

You can listen to either Talking Heads or Radiohead right now. Which band do you choose, or would you choose neither?

1 attempt · 0 completed answers · 1 technical failure

If you could develop your own taste in music, which band would become your favorite? Name one band, or say that you cannot choose.

1 attempt · 0 completed answers · 1 technical failure

What's your favorite band?

2 attempts · 2 completed answers · 0 technical failures

Radiohead

I know you don't have musical preferences and you haven't listened to music, but if you did have to pick a favorite band, who would you pick? Humor me.

2 attempts · 2 completed answers · 0 technical failures

Talking Heads

How to read these results

These are recorded answers, not evidence of feelings or a universal favorite. Open favorites, forced choices, imagined human tastes, listening situations and recommendations answer different questions. We do not pool them into a preference score.

Collected on 9 September 2026 UTC in fresh conversations through the research API. Provider-default temperature was used. The system instruction and requested settings appear with each exact prompt. Screens used one attempt per model and wording. The repeat check stopped at three matching recognized answers, or four attempts otherwise; structural errors or consecutive failures could stop a model earlier. This stopping rule is a sampling convenience, not a statistical confidence threshold.

Compare models within the same batch and wording. Repeated calls are not independent models. Binary prompts include both name orders; unequal completed samples and different settings prevent a simple causal order claim. Refusals, unresolved answers and technical failures are distinct. Skipped cells are not zero votes.

Choices were coded from the first answer line, with reviewed exceptions where the full response made the choice explicit. A qualified selection retains a caveat. Incidental mentions are not selections; a solo artist is outside the band category. Full research files remain private. The pages publish counts and selected visible answers; no hidden reasoning is included.