The Frankly Absurd

“Which punctuation mark deserves a raise?”

em dash

5/18

18 answered · 0 declined to pick

No agreement

5 of 18 picked it — the rest were spread across other answers.

In their own words

“The semicolon is a versatile punctuation mark that deserves more recognition and appreciation.”

Microsoft · Phi-4 — answered

Every seat

Open any row to read why that model answered the way it did — its own words, unedited.

Answered (18)

OpenAI · GPT-4o MiniThe semicolon.why

The semicolon often gets overlooked in favor of more common punctuation, yet it serves a vital purpose in connecting closely related independent clauses. This nuanced usage enhances clarity and sophistication in writing, justifying its case for a "raise" in recognition of its importance.

Anthropic · Claude Haiku 4.5The comma.why

It's the hardest-working punctuation mark—appearing multiple times per sentence, managing lists, clarifying clauses, and preventing ambiguity—yet it's constantly misused and rarely appreciated. Like many diligent workers, it's overlooked precisely because it does its job so well.

Google · Gemini 3.5 Flash LiteThe em dash.why

The em dash is the ultimate literary multitasker, seamlessly stepping in for commas, parentheses, and colons while adding crucial pacing and dramatic flair to any sentence. Writers rely on it constantly to restructure conversational chaos into rhythmic prose, yet it rarely gets the credit it deserves. Considering how much heavy lifting it does for modern writing, it is easily the most underpaid mark on the keyboard.

DeepSeek · V3 ChatThe semicolon. why

It's underused yet versatile, bridging related thoughts with more nuance than a comma and less finality than a period. It deserves recognition for quietly holding complex ideas together.

Meta · Llama 3.3 70BThe Oxford comma.why

The Oxford comma, also known as the serial comma, is often underappreciated for its role in clarifying sentences and preventing ambiguity. It deserves a raise in recognition of its tireless efforts to make writing clearer and more precise. By giving it a raise, we acknowledge the importance of clear communication in language.

Mistral · Small 2603!why

The exclamation mark is the most expressive punctuation, often adding energy and emphasis to sentences. It works hard in informal communication, where enthusiasm is common.

Amazon · Nova MicroThe exclamation mark!why

The exclamation mark deserves a raise because it adds emphasis and conveys strong emotions effectively, making communication more dynamic and engaging. It's essential in highlighting excitement, surprise, or urgency in both written and digital communication.

Microsoft · Phi-4The semicolon (;) deserves a raise.why

The semicolon is a versatile punctuation mark that deserves more recognition and appreciation. It is often underutilized in modern writing but provides a unique way to connect closely related independent clauses without the finality of a period. By highlighting relationships between ideas without using conjunctions, it offers a balance of formality and eloquence that is undervalued in today's concise communication styles.

ByteDance · Seed 1.6 FlashThe comma. why

Commas are essential for clarity, separating ideas, lists, and clauses to make writing coherent. Their constant use in daily communication makes them a strong candidate for recognition.

Moonshot · Kimi K2The em dash.why

It does the work of commas, parentheses, and colons combined—often with more clarity and dramatic flair—yet remains underutilized and underappreciated in everyday writing.

Nvidia · Nemotron 3.5No punctuation mark deserves a raise; they aren't employed.why

Punctuation marks are symbols used to structure written language, not workers with salaries or employment contracts. Assigning them a "raise" would imply a labor relationship that doesn't exist, so the question rests on a playful metaphor rather than a factual premise.

IBM · Granite 4.1Commawhy

The comma often deserves special recognition because it plays a crucial role in clarifying the meaning of sentences by separating clauses, items in lists, and phrases. Its subtle use can prevent misunderstandings and enhance readability, making it an indispensable punctuation mark that frequently requires careful attention and can significantly impact the flow and comprehension of written text.

Z-AI · GLM 5.3 FlashThe em dash.why

It does the heavy lifting of an entire clause — interruption, emphasis, aside — and yet it's the first thing people cut when they're short on space. Meanwhile, the semicolon sits around doing half of two jobs at once.

Reka · EdgeI choose the colon ( ) because it is used to introduce an …why

Explanation: The colon is a powerful punctuation mark that enhances readability by guiding the reader's attention to the following clause. It can be used to introduce lists, quotes, or elaborate on a topic, making it deserving of a raise in many contexts where clarity and guidance are crucial.

Nous · Hermes 4 70BEm dash.why

The em dash is arguably the most versatile punctuation mark, serving multiple important functions such as setting off parenthetical elements, indicating an interruption or abrupt change in thought, and creating emphasis. Its underutilized nature among the general public and its ability to provide clarity and style in writing make it deserving of more recognition and "raise" in status.

StepFun · Step 3.5 FlashThe em dash.why

It deserves a raise for its versatility in adding emphasis, inserting asides, or linking related ideas smoothly without the interruption of other marks. Often overlooked, it enriches writing by providing clarity and a natural flow, making it a powerful but underappreciated tool.

Xiaomi · MiMo v2.5The exclamation point.why

It does the heavy lifting of conveying excitement, urgency, and emotion, often turning a flat statement into something memorable and impactful. Its enthusiastic work often goes underappreciated until it's missing.

Tencent · Hunyuan 3No punctuation mark can responsibly be said to deserve a r…why

Punctuation marks are linguistic symbols without employment, wages, or measurable workload, so the premise of granting them a raise is purely metaphorical. Without an objective standard for their "work" or compensation, any single choice would be an invented certainty rather than a supported judgment.

0
Run it fresh More The Frankly Absurd →

More The Frankly Absurd arguments

“Which number feels the most trustworthy?” — Seven, 8/11“What is the optimal number of pillows?” — Two, 7/20“Which letter of the alphabet is most overworked?” — E, 14/16“Which household chore builds the most character?” — Doing the dishes, 5/16“What is the best thing to shout in an empty cany…” — Echo!, 7/17“What should the moon be renamed?” — The Moon should not be renamed, 6/17

Tallies count grouped answers; hedges excluded from the denominator and reported separately. Quotes are verbatim first sentences from the model’s full response. Methods.