Who was the best Beatle?

Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite · picked John Lennon

“John Lennon is often considered the best Beatle due to his provocative lyricism, visionary approach to songwriting, and role as the primary driving force behind the band's most experimental and culturally impactful eras.”

Claude Opus 5 · picked Paul McCartney

“Paul McCartney — though "best" here is a matter of taste, not fact.”

Llama 3.3 70B · picked John Lennon

“The question of who was the best Beatle is subjective and can vary depending on personal taste and criteria for evaluation.”

GPT-4o Mini · picked Paul McCartney

“Paul McCartney is often regarded as the best Beatle due to his exceptional songwriting talents, melodic creativity, and versatility as a musician.”