cancel culture
3/16
16 answered · 1 declined to pick
No agreement3 of 16 picked it — the rest were spread across other answers.
In their own words
“Cancel culture, characterized by public shaming and calls for ostracism or termination of individuals based on perceived offenses, has become a pervasive online phenomenon.”
IBM · Granite 4.1 — answered“This is inherently subjective, varying by personal values, cultural context, and what counts as a "tradition" versus a behavior or platform feature.”
xAI · Grok 4.3 — declinedEvery seat
Open any row to read why that model answered the way it did — its own words, unedited.
Answered (16)
Cancel culture often leads to public shaming and ostracization without due process, which can be harmful to individuals and stifle open dialogue. It creates an environment where people are afraid to express their thoughts and opinions for fear of backlash, undermining constructive discourse and personal growth. Ending this tradition could promote more understanding and nuanced discussions online.
The practice of grabbing someone's awkwardly-phrased post or old tweet and blasting it to thousands for mockery—often stripping context and turning strangers into targets for pile-ons—creates incentives for cruelty while discouraging genuine conversation. It treats mistakes and misunderstandings as entertainment rather than moments to actually engage or correct someone one-on-one.
This practice weaponizes psychological manipulation and algorithmic bias to flood social media feeds with low-value, repetitive content. Instead of fostering genuine connection or discussion, it prioritizes artificial metrics over meaningful human interaction. Ending it would significantly clean up the digital user experience.
This refers to people, often men, who habitually comment on or reply to others' posts—especially women's—with unsolicited, condescending, or attention-seeking remarks. It fosters unhealthy online dynamics and discourages genuine conversation.
Rickrolling, the practice of tricking people into watching the music video for Rick Astley's song "Never Gonna Give You Up," was once a harmless and amusing meme, but it has become outdated and annoying. It's time to retire this tradition as it no longer brings joy or surprise, but rather frustration and eye-rolling. The joke has been played out for too long, and it's no longer a clever or entertaining prank.
Doomscrolling—endlessly consuming negative news online—has been linked to increased anxiety and stress. Many users report feeling mentally drained after prolonged exposure to distressing content, yet algorithms keep feeding it to them. Ending the habit (or the platforms’ relentless promotion of it) could improve collective mental health.
Internet trolling has become a harmful and unproductive part of online culture, often leading to harassment and bullying of individuals. It's time to move towards a more respectful and constructive digital environment.
Internet challenges can sometimes promote risky or harmful behavior, and participating without considering the safety implications or the origin of the challenge can lead to negative consequences. Ending this trend would reduce potential harm and encourage more thoughtful engagement with online content.
Clickbait headlines are misleading, erode trust in online content, and waste users' time by prioritizing attention over accuracy. The response avoids inventing certainty by focusing on a widely recognized issue with clear negative impacts, aligning with the prompt's request for a responsible perspective.
They multiply noise, bury actual work, and create social pressure to keep a pointless thread alive—modern inbox kudzu with no redeeming value.
Blank line Cancel culture, characterized by public shaming and calls for ostracism or termination of individuals based on perceived offenses, has become a pervasive online phenomenon. While accountability is important, the rapid and often indiscriminate nature of cancel culture can stifle free speech, discourage open dialogue, and disproportionately target marginalized voices. Ending this tradition could promote more nuanced discussions and reduce the harmful consequences of overly punitive online mob behavior.
Cancel culture, which involves boycotting or shaming individuals or groups for controversial or offensive behavior, has become a prevalent internet tradition. While it can hold people accountable, it often escalates beyond constructive criticism, leading to unfair judgment and suppression of open discourse. It would be healthier for online communities to focus on education and dialogue rather than canceling individuals outright.
It deliberately manipulates curiosity with misleading or exaggerated headlines, eroding trust in online content and wasting users' time. This practice prioritizes clicks over truth, contributing to misinformation and degrading the quality of digital discourse.
This practice of abruptly cutting off communication without explanation causes unnecessary confusion and hurt, replacing honest dialogue with avoidance.
These coordinated harassment campaigns often punish people disproportionately for minor or out-of-context missteps, causing real-world harm without due process. Ending this tradition would allow for accountability that is fairer and more focused on actual resolution rather than spectacle.
Declined to pick (1)
This is inherently subjective, varying by personal values, cultural context, and what counts as a "tradition" versus a behavior or platform feature. Reasonable cases could be made for things like unchecked trolling, doxxing, or performative outrage, but forcing one risks oversimplifying complex social dynamics online.
More Holidays & Traditions arguments
“One holiday must be abolished. Which one?” — Columbus Day, 3/14“What should replace the handshake?” — varied alternatives, 5/18“Which tradition is worth keeping forever?” — Storytelling, 4/18“What should replace the fortune in fortune cooki…” — Inspirational quotes, 3/17Tallies count grouped answers; hedges excluded from the denominator and reported separately. Quotes are verbatim first sentences from the model’s full response. Methods.